It is several years already I trying some Air Quality monitors. And I think it is time to post some of the results. So here it is. Overview of some Air Quality monitors tested so far.
For me perfect device is the one:
- measure correctly
- measure multiple parameters
- display information locally
- has a battery and can be used as a mobile tool
- is an IoT device with Wi-Fi connectivity and mobile app
- not cost a fortune
- quiet
Some of the requirements are cannot (or at least not easy to) be met simultaneously. A lot of advanced sensors with Wi-Fi connectivity and good mobile application make the device expensive. Battery and battery charging circuits usually affect temperature and relative humidity measurements. Active airflow improves measurement speed and quality but makes devices noisy. So there is no single perfect device yet to cover all Air Quality Monitor use cases. That is why I choose some devices I like more by category.
IoT Air Quality Monitors
Best IoT Air Quality Monitor “award” goes to AWAIR 2
- ✔️Good design
- ✔️Local data display
- ✔️IoT device with a nice mobile application
- ✔️Good hardware design (airflow, antennas, etc.)
- ✔️ CO2, PM2.5, VOC, temperature, humidity
- ❌Not all sensors are perfect
- ❌No iPad application
- ❌No battery
- ❌Noise
- 170-200$
So as you can see above the device is not perfect. It is noisy, that is how good airflow and better measurement quality and speed achieved. Some Sensors are not the best in class, that is how the price is lower than 200$. For more details see AWAIR 2 Review.
IoT Alternatives
uHoo
✔️ quiet, more parameters (CO, O3, NO2), iPad app
❌ expensive (330$), cheaper sensors, no local display
AirVisual Pro (Node)
✔️ large display, outdoor data for PM2.5, battery, iPad app
❌ more expensive (280$), fewer parameters (no VOC)
Netatmo Smart Home Weather Station (Urban Weather)
✔️ quiet, weather station (external t/RH module), iPad app, 180$
❌ fewer parameters (no PM2.5, no VOC), poor CO2 sensor
✔️ quiet, more parameters (HCHO), iPad app
❌ Bluetooth or additional hub, single color status LED, 330$
Airthings Wave Plus
✔️ quiet, Radon sensor, work from 2xAA, iPad app, 200-270$
❌ fewer parameters (no PM2.5)
Portable Monitors
Best Portable Air Quality Monitor “award” goes to K6-D
- ✔️Several hours of battery life
- ✔️Good Sensors
- ✔️ CO2, PM2.5, VOC, temperature, humidity
- ✔️ Low price ~100$
- ❌Humidity measurements not perfect
- ❌No connectivity
- ❌Noise
Again, as it was with the best IoT device, this one is not perfect. It is noisy, it has no Wi-Fi/Bluetooth/etc, humidity measurements may show -10% RH on high humidity tests, but still, it is better than some others and good for the price.
Portable Alternatives
✔️ additional HCHO Sensor
❌ less temperature/humidity accuracy, 110$
AirVisual Pro (Node)
✔️ less noisy, large display, outdoor data for PM2.5, battery, IoT
❌ more expensive (280$), fewer parameters (no VOC)
✔️ large display
❌ wrong temperature and humidity, cheaper sensors, ~110$
✔️ small
❌ CO2 only, ~124$ , battery sold separately, auto power-off
✔️ PC app for data logging
❌ wrong temperature and humidity, no VOC, no PM2.5 ~80$
Airthings wave plus
✔️ quiet, Radon sensor, months of work from 2xAA
❌ fewer parameters (no PM2.5), 200-270$, single LED local status display.
Other Air Quality Monitors
Best in Most Trusted device category is Green Day AZ7788
- ✔️Correct measurements
- ✔️Old, but a good type of sensors
- ✔️ Relay output
- ❌Only C02
- ❌No connectivity
- ❌No battery
- ~110$
Old school device with separate analog temperature and humidity sensors, Old model of CO2 sensor. No other air quality sensors present. Need to be always plugged. But still one of the best in measurement quality.
More technical details you can find below
Devices inside https://wiki.liutyi.info/display/CO2/Monitors
Devices t/RH tests: low humidity test mid humidity test high humidity test changing humidity timelapse
More on Air Quality topic may be found at https://seetheair.wordpress.com/